Contra Proferentem is not a principle of universal application and it does not merit applicability in case of commercial contracts, for a clause in a commercial contract is bilateral and has mutually been agreed upon. Any question as to unconscionableness of a stipulation contained in an agreement would probably arise for consideration only if it […]
Read more "The Contra Proferentem Rule VIII"Doctrine of Separation of Powers is not merely philosophical. – Hon’ble Former Chief Justice of India, Hon’ble Justice B.R. Gavai, Madras Bar Association v. Union of India, [Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1018 of 2021]. _____ “We are not final because we are infallible, but we are infallible only because we are final.” We have rather […]
Read more "The Nature of Judicial Power: One Battle After Another"It is an eye-opener for one and all. In State of Kerala v. N.M. Thomas, (1976) 2 SCC 310, A.N. Ray, CJ (as he then was), noted, varying needs of different classes of persons require special treatment. It was cautioned, equality cannot mean absolute equality. In other words, equality would only mean parity of treatment […]
Read more "Transgender Protection Cell / The Revival of Ray XCVIII"Vaneeta Patnaik is a Faculty Member of West Bengal National University of Juridical Sciences. Dr. Nirmal Kanti Chakrabarti was appointed as a Vice Chancellor of NUJS on 03.07.2019. September, 2019 – Dr. Nirmal insisted Vaneeta should accompany him for dinner. He even touched Vaneeta in a manner that made her extremely uncomfortable. October, 2019 – […]
Read more "Dr. Nirmal Kanti Chakrabarti"The jurisprudential divide between irregular and illegal appointments is neither artificial nor academic Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi, (2006) 4 SCC 1 held, mere technical irregularities in appointment processes, in absence of evidence of illegality, arbitrariness or fraud, cannot be a ground to undo appointments, especially when appointees are not at fault. Vikas Pratap […]
Read more "The Baishakhi Principle"Democracy, in its essence, means a society governed by elected representatives of people based on universal adult franchise in a free and transparent manner. Thus, free and fair elections go to the root of a functional democracy. Lok Prahari v. Union of India, (2018) 4 SCC 699 summarized the legal and contextual position regarding non-disclosure of assets […]
Read more "Consequential or Inconsequential Import"Air Force has continually opened new Combat Air Force Roles for Women as Fighter Pilots, Helicopter Pilots, et cetera. It does not stand to reason, when Women Officers like Captain Ojaswita Shree, Major Dwipannita Kalita and Flight Lieutenant Shivangi Singh can operate behind enemy lines with all expected risks, why Women Officers in times of […]
Read more "Women Officers"The Chief Justice of India bears a significant moral responsibility to ensure, Judiciary functions in a transparent, efficient and constitutionally appropriate manner. The Chief Justice of India is clearly an important person in maintaining institutional interest and credibility. The Chief Justice of India owes a duty to keep our justice delivery system pure, clean and […]
Read more "Where Eagles Dare"Secunderabad Club v. CIT, 2023 INSC 736 had occasion to delineate how to cull out ratio decidendi and identify principles which have precedential value. Further, a simple test has been invoked by this Court. Professor Eugene Wambaugh’s ‘Inversion Test’ mandates, to determine whether a particular proposition of law is part of ratio decidendi, either that […]
Read more "Ratio Decidendi IV"R.M. Malkani v. State of Maharashtra, (1973) 2 SCR 417 is locus classicus on determining admissibility of a tape-recorded conversation. When this Court decided Yusufalli Esmail Nagree v. State of Maharashtra, AIR 1968 SC 147 and R.M. Malkani, devices like tape-recorders and microphones were carefully placed in a space wherein conversations could be secretly recorded […]
Read more "Spill the Beans"Were this an ordinary civil suit, we could have possibly applied ‘preponderance of probabilities’ which may have resulted in some leeway and latitude in favour of D. Kumar (Election Petitioner) and against A. Raja. However, as per J. Chandrasekhara Rao v. V. Jagapathi Rao, 1993 Supp (2) SCC 229 and M. Chandra v. M. Thangamuthu, […]
Read more "Judges & Politicians & Social Media"Manoj Parihar v. State of Jammu and Kashmir, (2022) 14 SCC 72 opined, Doctrine of Prospective Overruling must be exercised in explicit terms and therefore, law declared by this Court would have a retrospective effect unless stated otherwise. It would not be an absolute rule, prospective overruling or prospective operation of a decision must be […]
Read more "The Doctrine of Prospective Overruling III"Courts have authority to determine appropriate interest rate, considering totality of facts and circumstances in accordance with law. That apart, Courts have discretion to decide whether interest is payable from date of institution of suit, a period prior to that, or from date of decree, depending on specific facts of each case. Court must ensure, […]
Read more "Costs Jurisprudence III: Interest Rates"“Those who are blood thirsty, listen to us. If a fight for our rights is met with injustice, we will meet that injustice with love. If drops flowing from a candle are like a flame, we will use it to light up all paths if bodies of our loved ones are a threat to your […]
Read more "Hon’ble Justice Abhay S. Oka’s Beautiful Mind"Indian Council of Social Science Research is under total financial and administrative control of Ministry of Education, Government of India. Centre for Research in Rural and Industrial Development is under grant-in-aid of ICSSR. But, this itself cannot be called a ‘deep and pervasive control’. A ‘deep and pervasive control’ would require much more than just […]
Read more "Deep and Pervasive Control"A ‘stigma’ is indicative of a blemish, disgrace indicating a deviation from a norm. Where there is a discharge from service after prescribed probation period was completed and discharge was not based solely on assessment of employee’s work and conduct during probation, termination was held to be ‘stigmatic’ and punitive [Jaswantsingh Pratapsingh Jadeja v. Rajkot […]
Read more "Stigma"“We may reiterate, therefore, the certificate required under Section 65B(4) is a condition precedent to admissibility of evidence by way of electronic record, as correctly held in Anvar P.V. v. P.K. Basheer, (2014) 10 SCC 473.” Arjun Panditrao Khotkar v. Kailash Kushanrao Gorantyal, (2020) 3 SCC 216 referred and Three-Judge Bench in Arjun Panditrao Khotkar […]
Read more "Review of Death Penalty XLIII"The evidence collected during course of investigation in a legal and proper manner and sought to be used in course of trial with regard to a seized contraband substance could not be simply brushed aside on ground of a procedural irregularity committed. Union of India v. Mohanlal, (2016) 3 SCC 379 nowhere held, non-compliance or […]
Read more "Section 52A of The NDPS Act"After a few mediation sessions before Supreme Court Mediation Centre, Sandesh submitted before us, he was not interested in pursuing a mediated settlement before Supreme Court Mediation Centre. However, Rinku and Sandesh agreed to attempt a mediated settlement before a Retired Judge of this Court. Consequently, Retd. Justice S. Ravindra Bhat was appointed as a […]
Read more "Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage IV"We need to examine whether possibility of reformation is completely ruled out. Sambhubhai was 24, had no criminal antecedents and hails from a low socio-economic household as The Mitigation Investigation Report, filed by Project 39A, indicates. The Mitigation Report further indicates, Sambhubhai maintains family ties with his 64-year-old Mother who takes care of his 10-year-old […]
Read more "Review of Death Penalty XLII"
The Last Word 
You must be logged in to post a comment.